How To Track Grades and Transcripts for High School Homeschool

You can keep track of younger kids’ grades if you want to (or if your state requires you to), but in high school you must track your student’s grades.  The high school grades are necessary for college admissions, military admission, and sometimes for jobs, even years after graduation.  Here we’ll explain how to track grades and transcripts for high school homeschool.  Then we’ll talk about a few options for getting into college.

The first thing you must understand about grading a class is that there is no firm method or set way of doing so.  There are some conventions, but each teacher can decide the criteria for her own class and how to award grades.  Whatever system you do choose though should be fair and consistent.  So let’s start with the conventions.

Grading Conventions

  1. High school grades in the United States are awarded in a letter system, A through F.  You probably shouldn’t change that up because it’s what college admissions offices understand and we do need to all speak the same language.  Besides, it ain’t broke.
  2. Generally letter grades are awarded based on a percentage out of a hundred.  It’s a simple and intuitive way to grade.
  3. The final convention is that individual grades on homework, projects, tests and so on are averaged up to make the final grade.  Final grades are not arbitrarily decided on out of thin air by the teacher.  If you want your child’s transcript to be credible later on, you need to be able to clearly explain how grades were arrived at.  “I felt he had mastered the subject” isn’t really acceptable in the grown up world. “He completed all reading assignments, scored highly on essays, and participated in discussions about the reading” is much more to the point.

Grading Math

So let’s take an example of a class and how to grade it.  Math is probably the easiest subject to grade so we’ll start there.  Most high school (and college) teachers give full credit for completed math homework regardless of how many correct answers were arrived at.  You can do the same.

Whatever math curriculum you have for high school should have tests of some sort.  Grade the tests based on correct answers.  Sometime teachers will give partial credit for an answer, especially if all work is shown and the student has understood the principle, but perhaps made an arithmetic error.  It’s up to you if you decide to give partial credit for some answers, but you need to decide how you will grade at the beginning and be consistent.  Some teachers allow students to retake a test if the student does poorly, some teachers do not.  Again, it’s up to you, but decide your policy from the beginning and stick to it.

Math Grades At Our House

At our house we also do daily math facts practice, even through high school.  I give credit for daily drilling as well.  Finally, most math teachers weight the scores from homework and the scores from tests differently.  For example, they might think the homework should be sixty percent of the grade and the tests should be thirty percent of the grade and attendance at lectures be worth ten percent of the grade.  You can make the same judgement calls.

At our house math facts practice is given a weight of 20%, homework is 60%, and tests are 20%.  Our homework is do or die.  If you don’t complete even one assigned problem for the day, nothing on the page counts.  I do that because I want my kids to do the work, to practice, and put the effort in.  It is important to have reasons for why you decide to grade the way you do.

Grading English

English is a bit trickier to grade. Most English classes, especially the freshman and sophomore years, will involve more than just reading and writing papers.  They will also include grammar, spelling/vocab, instruction on how to write papers, oral presentations, projects, and more.  Each of these elements will be graded differently.

Grammar, Spelling, and Vocab

Grammar is usually handled though a workbook, in which case completed work gets a hundred percent and failure to finish gets a zero.  Some people do grammar more on the fly, they point out errors in their kid’s writing and teach a mini-grammar lesson right then and there.  If that’s your method, you may not want to grade grammar, but just leave it as an element of grading when you give a score on papers and other writing.  Spelling and vocab can be handled similarly to grammar.


Most teachers grade reading by giving comprehension quizzes or tests on assigned reading.  We don’t do that at home.  I have avid readers who can’t get enough, so I never worry whether they’ve completed the reading assignment.  Also, I’m sitting right there watching them read.  My eagle eye never rests. So I grade based on “did it or didn’t do it”.  Either method is fine as long as you are consistent.


Now the hardest thing in the world to grade is the paper.  Grading a paper is sort of subjective.  It’s not like math where there’s a single right answer.  So what you need is a method. Karen, brilliant English teacher type that she is, has a perfect system that I’ve been using for years . . . she saved my bacon with this method.  

It uses six traits of writing: ideas and content, organization, word choice, sentence fluency, conventions, and voice. Instead of trying to pick a grade out of thin air, you give points in each of these sections, with a maximum of five points possible for each section. If the ideas are unique and interesting, you would give five points. If the ideas are a bit tired, more like repetition than originality, then you would give 1 point. As you give points you keep in mind the child’s current ability as a writer. You aren’t comparing the writer to the best literature you’ve ever read, you are comparing him to himself. Has his ability to come up with original ideas improved? Then give him five points!

Using a rubric and breaking the paper down into specific skills helps focus your grading and give useful feedback to the writer. You can learn more about how to grade writing by reading Guidebook: How to Create a Writer’s Workshop.

Grading History

History usually has elements of reading and writing.  You may have tests, quizzes, and projects too.  I grade history in four elements:

  1. Reading (which is either you did it or you didn’t)
  2. Writing (essays usually 1/2 to 1 page long summaries of what they’ve learned, which I grade like English papers)
  3. Projects, which are graded like the English papers as well except since there is often no actual writing involved, mechanics doesn’t come into it.  Following the assignment, completing it, doing your best work, and presentation all count.
  4. Tests or quizzes

Grading Science

Science consists of reading, lab work (which is sometimes more like projects than actual labs), and worksheets.  Your science program might have tests or homework with written work.  I weight our science reading heavily.  My kids don’t read science texts very often.  Instead they read the works of real scientists.  Tim is reading “A Brief History of Time” by Stephen Hawking right now because we’re studying astronomy.  So our reading is pretty substantial and important.  You might have a program that emphasizes lectures and hands on labs and in that case you would weight the labs more heavily.  The key is to think through which elements your program uses for teaching the subject and separate these elements into categories for grading purposes.  Each of these elements will become your sub-subjects and get their own column on the grading sheet.

Grading Geography

First, let me say that people neglect geography in high school.  Other than the Layers of Learning curriculum I’m not sure I’ve ever heard of another homeschool geography course for teens.  Geography isn’t just about maps and locations, though those are very important all by themselves.  It is about culture, language, governments, the shape of the earth, and current events.  Geography is the study of people as they are on earth at this moment in time.  So many homeschoolers are so into history (me included) but they forget that people alive right now today are the ones who are making history, and that is the study of geography.

But I digress.

Maps, Projects, and Quizzes

Geography should have elements of maps, projects, and quizzes.

Assign maps with clear guidelines – lists of what to include and clear directions on what you expect the final product to look like (neatly labeled in black ink, neatly colored with colored pencils, etc.).  Grade based on those guidelines.  The English paper grading method we use should give you an idea of how to set up a grading system for something like a map as well.

Projects include crafts, food, current events, and research presentations.  Grade based on the criteria you gave when you explained the assignment to your kid.

Quizzes are fabulous in geography.  You want a certain mastery of the countries, land forms, and features of Earth.  A quiz might consist of handing your student a blank map of Africa and asking them to label the countries.  Divide the number they get right by the possible points to get the percentage that you enter into the grading sheet.

Grading The Arts

The arts at our house includes great literature, plays, and poetry, painting, sculpture, music, and dance.  We do an amalgamated art appreciation/art execution course perpetually.  But you can also do a semester long dedicated drama course or watercolor painting course.  My sub-subjects under the arts are projects and reading.  Because so much of our course is art appreciation and because we use literature elements we have quite a bit of reading.  You may only have projects, depending on how you do art.  I grade everything in this subject as done or not done.  If they basically follow the direction given and complete the project or the reading then they get full credit.  You could also use quizzes.

Grading Foreign Language

You probably use a program of some sort for foreign language if you do foreign language at all.  Even if you are fluent in a second language or have a neighbor who is, your kids should probably be doing grammar and written exercises in the foreign language.  Generally foreign languages have daily work and drills to complete and weekly or periodic tests.  Grade daily work based on completion.  For a five day week award 20% for each day completed.  Then the scores for all five days fit in a single box, and the student has to complete an entire week of exercises to equal the work of one test. Grade foreign language tests with simple percentages.

Grading Other Courses


Teens take a wide variety of classes from computer programming to wood shop and it would be impossible to cover all the possibilities here.  But there are some basics you may have picked up in the above grading descriptions.  First you decide which elements of the class are being used to teach.  Is there a reading element? A testing element? A project element?  Grade each of these in separate categories.  Next, weight each category depending on what you believe to be the most important.  Decide if an element will be graded as “done or not done” or if it can be graded with an actual percentage of right and wrong answers.  Then just average your graded elements together using a weight system.

A Spreadsheet for Grading

Below you can see the Gradebook from Layers of Learning.  This is a spreadsheet you can open in Google Sheets, Excel, Libre Office or another spreadsheet program. It is formatted to calculate grades based on scores you enter in.

Visit the product page for the gradebook to see how it works.

The Transcript

Transcripts sound so very official. The good news for you is that they are.  And you are perfectly qualified to write one.  You may need to back it up though, which is why it’s important to also keep detailed grading sheets, lists of the course materials you’ve used, and a portfolio of your child’s best work.

The Gradebook includes a sheet for the transcript, which can be printed directly from the spreadsheet program top make an official transcript for your homeschool graduate.

Getting Into College

If your kids are college-bound, there are some good options for getting in.  You should definitely keep grades and prepare a transcript.  You should also have them take the SAT or a similar college entrance exam.

The SAT is normally taken in the spring of the Junior year, but it can be taken a bit earlier or later.  Your student can also take it more than once if his or her first try isn’t the greatest.  PSATs can be taken during the sophomore year or in the fall of the junior year.  They provide practice and if your student does well, they can also generate scholarship offers.

Community College

This is my favorite college entrance path.  Community colleges are a great gateway between homeschool and full college life.  The classes tend to be small and the professors more accessible. Most community colleges let high school age kids begin taking classes.  They typically have simple placement exams and an easy application process, which doesn’t generally require a diploma. Once you’ve begun community college, it becomes easy to apply to other colleges using a homeschool transcript, an SAT score, and your community college transcript.


More and more universities are accepting just a homeschool transcript as well as an SAT score. Contact the admissions offices of several universities.  Find out what they require.  Do it at the beginning of your high school years.  They may have specific requirements like 2 years of foreign language, 3 science credits, and so on.  Find out early so you can make sure you cover those while in high school.

Online Courses

Some homeschool families decide to switch to an online at home charter school scenario during high school.  If completed, these programs award a high school diploma at the end.  Some colleges also have online programs that high school students can enroll in for credit.


You can also take the GED and use that as you apply to colleges.  It is equivalent to a diploma. Some people feel it carries a stigma, but more and more colleges have adapted to the diversity of educational opportunities for kids and are treating it the same as a diploma. As of 2017 the military still requires homeschooled students to obtain a GED before they will be accepted.

High School Curriculum

Layers of Learning is a complete curriculum for high schoolers. We use a great books and living books approach rather than a text book approach.  The history and geography are thorough and in depth. Science includes links to video lectures, outside reading, and high school level experiments that you can do at home.  The arts integrates poetry, literature, art principles, art appreciation, and music into one complete course.

Take a look at our curriculum guide to see if it might be for you.

Free Samples

Try family-style homeschooling now with free samples of four Layers of Learning units when you subscribe. You'll get to try family-style history, geography, science, and arts with your children.

You can unsubscribe any time.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Scroll to Top